Have you ever gone three or more weeks without electricity because of a hurricane, tornado, or some other disaster? I have, and I can tell you from experience that even for a short term scenario, managing fuel is not as easy as it looks. Each of these situations gave me a chance to gain some very tangible experience with fuel storage issues. When considering propane vs. kerosene, it is not enough to just consider the basic characteristics of the fuel or how much energy it will produce. You must also consider storage safety long term changes in the fuel. This article will give you an introduction to propane and kerosene as well as advantages and disadvantages of storing each one for survival needs.
An Introduction to Propane
Propane is actually a gaseous form of petroleum. When propane is compacted 270 times more than normal pressure, it turns into a liquid that is easy to transport. There are two ways to get propane:
- propane can be extracted from natural gas. In this case, butane, and ethane (both volatile gasses) must be removed so that the remaining propane is safe to transport through natural gas lines.
- Propane is also released while petroleum is being turned into heating oil and gasoline.
- This fuel is considered cleaner than others because there are fewer emissions. It is also considered better for the environment because it can be extracted from a “renewable” natural sources such as waste from farm animals, trash dumps, and home based methane reactors.
Problems With Storing Propane
Propane is usually stored in tanks that range in size from 1 pound to 420 pounds. There are also larger sized tanks available, however, they require a special permit. Regardless of the tank size, great care must be taken when storing propane because:
- This gas is poisonous and can kill if you breathe it in or ingest it.
- Propane is also highly volatile. If there is a leak in the tank, it can cause an explosion if the escaping gas contacts a spark or something else hot enough to ignite it.
- If the weather is very cold, propane can loose its ability to evaporate and can’t be used. You will need to know how to manage these issues in order to use propane safely.
Key Advantages of Storing Propane
Storing Propane for survival use will give you a larger choice of equipment than many other fuels. This includes generators, cooking stoves, lamps, and all kinds of camping equipment. Propane can also be stored in tanks for many years without breaking down into other chemicals.
Here are some other advantages:
- Propane is used throughout the country and is available in many stores. If you are careful about where you acquire the tanks and how you store them, it is possible to stockpile propane without being noticed.
- Even if you do not use the propane for many years, it is still likely to ignite and burn cleanly without any problems.
An Introduction to Kerosene
According to efoods Direct, “Although kerosene has become less common in the United States, it is still commonly used in Japan and in developing nations. The Amish use kerosene for their lighting at night.”
Kerosene is a clear, flammable liquid made from petroleum. After processing, manufacturers add red dye to some kerosene. Red or K-1 kerosene is intended for home heating while undyed kerosene is intended for transportation. Since kerosene for transportation carries a higher federal tax, most kerosene is dyed red to avoid that problem.
For prepping and home use, kerosene can be used as fuel for heaters, lamps, and stoves. Even though kerosene has almost twice as much energy as Propane, it gives off carbon monoxide and a distinctive odor. If you use kerosene indoors, you must also have adequate air flow because the fumes can cause headaches and even death.
Problems With Storing Kerosene
Kerosene can be stored in cans or tanks of all sizes, however, reside from old gas cans, chemical drums, or other used containers can contaminate the kerosene. I normally store kerosene in clean, new, sealed containers that are clearly marked for kerosene storage. If kerosene becomes contaminated, it may not burn correctly, or it may release more toxic fumes.
Here are some problems you may encounter even with the best storage methods:
- Kerosene has a shelf life of approximately five years.
- Water vapor or condensation will ruin kerosene over time. This may happen faster if you use plastic containers.
- Bacteria and mold can also live in kerosene and act to break it down.
- If the kerosene appears cloudy or yellow, it may not burn right.
- Can’t be stored as long as propane
- you can try adding stabilizers to the kerosene, however they may not extend the life of the fuel by that much
- If you try to use kerosene that has gone past its shelf life, it may still burn. Unfortunately, it can also cause wicks to foul and create other problems that will ruin your equipment.
- If you live in an area where kerosene is used as a heating fuel, you can stockpile it without drawing much attention to yourself.
- Containers for storing kerosene are cheaper and easier to obtain.
Key Advantages of Storing Kerosene
After using propane and kerosene during hurricanes and other disasters, I honestly don’t feel that kerosene would work well for longer-term scenarios. Aside from being very dangerous to use in confined areas, it simply doesn’t have the shelf life of Propane, nor is it as reliable. From a storage point of view alone, it does cost a bit more to store propane. In the long run, I have greater confidence that propane will ignite and burn correctly no matter whether it is stored for just a day or as long as a decade.
Have you ever lived for weeks or even a few days without electricity? If you used propane or kerosene, I’d love to hear about your experiences. Did you find that storage methods were an important factor in how well each fuel performed during a crisis situation? Please feel free to share your conclusions about which fuel is better to store and how you arrived at that conclusion.
- The Best Places to Use Propane and Kerosene Heaters
- Kerosene Versus Propane – Things To Consider…
- Kerosene or Propane Heater for Preparedness
- Comparing Values of Various Heating Fuels
- Energy is the Key to Survival
Image by: Bob the Lomond